Most real life attempts have failed to reach the heights the collective talent merits.
1. Pick the best player at each position
2. Pick your favourite player at each position
3. Try to create a balanced line up that might actually work in real life.
However my pick is another legendary wild man, Keith Moon.
Was he a technically 'correct' drummer, no. Did he play 'correctly', no. Did he constantly overplay trying to grab the lime light? Absolutely.